TOPIC 1. WHY IS ACADEMIC WRITING IMPORTANT FOR STUDENTS IN HIGHER EDUCATION?

T1.1 Brainstorming

Welcome to the Academic Writing Course

This course is an opportunity for you to strengthen your academic writing skills, which are essential for your journey as future educators and researchers. Writing a scientific article is not merely an academic requirement, but also a way to train critical thinking, organize ideas logically, and communicate knowledge to the wider scholarly community.

In our first meeting, we will begin by reflecting on your experiences in reading and writing scientific papers. Why is this important? Because your prior experiences will serve as a foundation to better understand the challenges, needs, and expectations in learning how to write academic articles. Just as we learn to listen before we speak, engaging with journal articles through reading is a crucial first step before producing effective academic writing.

Academic writing is often considered challenging: the use of formal language, strict citation rules, and adherence to the IMRAD structure (Introduction, Method, Results, and Discussion). However, it is precisely through these challenges that we can develop critical thinking, problem-solving skills, and effective ways of presenting our research and ideas.

Throughout this course, you will be guided step by step: from asking questions (Questioning), gathering information, analyzing, drafting, revising, and finally preparing your article for submission and publication. In this first session, we will focus on the Questioning stage: reflecting on your journal reading experiences, identifying the most challenging aspects, and raising critical questions about how scientific articles are structured and written.

Worksheet 1.1 – Personal Reflection

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2520

    Please write about ONE of your most memorable experiences in reading a journal article. Then, answer the questions below:

    1. Briefly describe your experience in reading the article (What was the topic? When did you read it? How did you access it? What did you feel while reading it?).
    2. In your opinion, what made the experience memorable or challenging (e.g., the topic, the structure, the language, or the argumentation)?

    (To be discussed in class or onlione ) From your story and your classmates’ experiences, what can you conclude about the common challenges students face when reading journal articles?

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

T1.2 Individual Exploration

The Importance of Journal Article Publication

In this stage, you are expected to explore the significance of journal article publication in the academic community. Publishing in reputable journals is not only a way to share research findings but also a means of contributing to the advancement of knowledge, gaining recognition, and building academic credibility. By understanding the importance of publication, you will become more aware of the expectations and standards required in academic writing.

Through individual exploration, you will use journal finder tools (such as Elsevier Journal Finder or Taylor & Francis Journal Suggester) to identify journals relevant to your area of interest. This activity will help you understand how to match your research topic with suitable journals, analyze different article structures, and reflect on how published works can guide you in writing your own academic papers.

This task is designed to encourage independent learning, critical observation, and self-reflection before engaging in collaborative discussion with peers.

Worksheet 1.2 – Exploring Journal Articles through Journal Finders

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #3016

    Answer the questions below based on your own experience in finding and reading journal articles.

    1. Why do you think writing a scientific article is important for English education students?
      Which journal finder did you use?
    2. Find two or more journal articles on the same topic? Compare and find what similarities or differences did you notice in their structure or style?
    3. Which part of a journal article do you usually find the most difficult to understand (e.g., abstract, introduction, methodology, discussion, references)? Why?
    4. In your opinion, how does reading journal articles help you improve your own academic writing skills?
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

T.1.3 Sharing and Group Discussion

Scientific article writing is a process that involves many stages, from developing an idea to submitting a manuscript for publication. Each stage requires specific knowledge, skills, and awareness of the expectations set by journals and reviewers. For many students, understanding these stages can be difficult without real-life insights from experienced scholars or journal editors. Therefore, discussing and preparing questions as a group will help students clarify their understanding and focus on what they really want to know about the publication process.

Through group discussion, students have the opportunity to reflect on their own experiences with academic writing and connect them with the challenges of publishing in journals. By working collaboratively, they can generate meaningful questions that not only reflect their curiosity but also guide them toward a deeper understanding of what makes an article publishable. This process also encourages students to think critically, compare perspectives, and learn how to formulate academic inquiries.

The questions developed in this session will serve as the foundation for the upcoming interview with journal editors, reviewers, or lecturers with strong publication experience. This means that the quality of the questions created here will directly influence the depth of insights students can gain in the next stage. Therefore, it is important for each group to take the discussion seriously, explore different angles, and prepare clear and focused questions. This way, the interview will become a valuable learning experience about the realities of scientific publishing.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2565

    Worksheet 1.3 Generating Questions on Academic Writing and Journal Publication

    Instructions
    1. Form groups of 3–4 students.
    2. Discuss your experiences and knowledge about academic writing and journal article publication.
    3. Together, create a list of at least 2–3 questions for each of the following categories.
    4. Remember: The questions you create here will be used in the next meeting for an interview session with journal editors or reviewers, who will share their real experiences about why articles are accepted or rejected.
    5. The group leader gives response to the questions and list the name of the group members.
    Category 1 – Process

    Steps in writing a scientific article

    Category 2 – Quality

    Characteristics of a high-quality scientific article

    Category 3 – Challenges

    Common obstacles faced by writers and their solutions

    Category 4 – Resources

    Support, media, or tools needed for writing

    Category 5 – Structure & Content

    Main components of a Research Article (RA) in English Language Education

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

T. 1.4 Drafting and Refining

After completing the group discussion and compiling a list of questions, the next step is to refine and improve these questions so that they are ready to be used in a real interview setting. Since not all questions may be clear, focused, or relevant to the goals of scientific article writing and publication. Therefore, it is important to review, discuss, and polish the questions collaboratively before moving forward. 

In this stage, each group representative presents their list of questions to the class. Together with the lecturer, the class engages in an open discussion to examine the wording, clarity, and focus of each question. Suggestions for improvement are recorded directly in the worksheet table. After the refinement process, the final version of each question is marked with a ✔️ to indicate that it is ready for use in the upcoming Interview stage with editors or reviewers. This activity ensures that all questions are clear, practical, and aligned with real academic writing and publishing challenges, making them effective tools for further exploration.

Worksheet 1.4 – Refining and Finalizing Interview Questions

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #3022

    Instructions

    1. After completing Worksheet 1.3, bring your group’s draft questions to this worksheet.
    2. Review each question for clarity, focus, and relevance to scientific article writing and journal publication.
    3. Present your draft questions to the class. During the open discussion, note suggestions for improvement in the table.
    4. Revise your questions based on feedback. Mark the final version with a ✔️ once it is ready to be used in the upcoming Interview session with journal editors or reviewers.

    Refinement Table

    Draft Questions Suggestions for Improvement Final Version (✔️)
    Example:

    What makes a good research article?

    Be more specific:

    “What qualities do editors look for in the introduction of a research article?”

    What qualities do editors look for in the introduction of a research article?
     

     

       
        
     

     

     
     

     

     

       

     

     

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

T.1.5 Assignment

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2930

    Purpose:

    This activity aims to help you develop empathy and insight regarding the publication process by understanding the expectations, challenges, resources, and evaluation criteria used by journal editors and reviewers when assessing scientific articles.

    In this assignment, each group will conduct a field interview with a journal editor, reviewer, or lecturer who has extensive publication experience.

    Purpose

    The purpose of this activity is to help students gain deeper understanding of the publication process by exploring the expectations, challenges, resources, and evaluation criteria that are commonly applied in reviewing scientific articles.

    Instructions

    1. Prepare a set of interview questions based on the following categories:
      a. Process: Steps in writing and submitting a scientific article.
      b. Quality: Characteristics of a high-quality scientific article.
      c. Challenges: Common obstacles faced by authors during writing and submission.
      d. Resources: Support, tools, or resources needed for writing.
      e. Structure & Content: Main components that must be included in a research article.
    2. Arrange a schedule and conduct the interview in a professional manner.
    3. Take detailed notes during the interview, highlighting important advice, suggestions, and observations.
    4. Summarize the findings by identifying patterns, recurring feedback, and practical recommendations.

    Assignment Report

    Each group (represented by the group leader) submits a written report in the following discussion form that includes:

    1. Names and the student ID numbers
    2. Key insights from editors or reviewers.
    3. Frequent challenges faced by authors.
    4. Recommended resources and support for improving scientific writing.
    5. Suggestions for improving manuscript clarity, structure, and content.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.